Connect with us

According to the West Virginia Supreme Court, Anti-Gay assaults aren’t hate crimes

LGBT issues

According to the West Virginia Supreme Court, Anti-Gay assaults aren’t hate crimes

This past Tuesday, the West Virginia Supreme Court ruled in a 3-2 decision that their hate crime laws do not cover assaults against gay citizens, or any crimes committed on the basis of sexual orientation.

Mark Joseph Stern of Slate reports that West Virginia v. Butler, “emerged from a disturbing case of anti-gay bias.”

“In 2015, Steward Butler, a college football player, allegedly attacked two men for kissing in public after shouting homophobic slurs. Prosecutors charged Butler not only with battery but also with a hate crime. West Virginia’s hate crime statute does not explicitly include sexual orientation, but it does bar violence “because of sex.” Prosecutors argued that Butler’s alleged attack fell under this prohibition because it was motivated by sex stereotyping, and because sex lay at the root of the brutality: Butler allegedly beat each man for intimately associating with a person of the same sex, and if either were different sex, he would not have assailed them.”

The court’s Chief Justice, Allen H. Loughry II, ignored the precedent that interprets ‘sex’ as “the entire spectrum of disparate treatment of men and women resulting from sex stereotypes” and instead said that sex did not include sexual orientation. He did note, however, that the legislature has tried time and time again to get sexual orientation added to the state’s hate crime statute, but has repeatedly failed to do so.

Justice Margaret L. Workman fiercely disapproved of Loughry’s ruling, saying that he gave “the shortest shrift to real critical thinking.”

“If a man stands on a corner kissing a man and is beaten because he is kissing a man, has he been assaulted because of his sex? Yes, but not simply because he possesses male anatomical parts; rather, the crime occurred because he was perceived to be acting outside the social expectations of how a man should behave with a man. But for his sex, he would not have been attacked.

If a Caucasian man is fired because he is married to an African-American woman, has he been discriminated against because of his race? Yes, but not simply because of the hue of his skin; rather, the act was committed because he was perceived to be behaving outside the social expectation of how a Caucasian man should behave with an African American woman. But for his race, he would not have been fired.”

Unfortunately, Workman’s views represented the minority of the court. But all hope is not lost; Lambda Legal attorney Greg Nevins has filed amicus brief supporting the prosecution, and has been adamant in voicing his disappointment in the court’s ruling.

“It’s increasingly clear that we lose if judges focus on the words that aren’t in the statute,” he told Stern, “and win if they focus on the words that are in the statute. The West Virginia Supreme Court narrowly went for the old-school former approach, which was in vogue in the federal appellate courts a dozen years ago. But notably those courts are now realizing the error of their ways and moving towards getting it right.”

h/t: Slate

 

Continue Reading
247 Comments

247 Comments

  1. Pingback: URL

  2. Pingback: dump shops

  3. Pingback: บาคาร่า

  4. Pingback: Bank canada

  5. Pingback: White House Market URL

  6. Pingback: World Market Link

  7. Pingback: block screenshot

  8. Pingback: block android screenhot

  9. Pingback: fresh dumps

  10. Pingback: mega888

  11. Pingback: funeral home

  12. Pingback: Darknet Insider News

  13. Pingback: Dakrnet Guide

  14. Pingback: ww88

  15. Pingback: Order Amoxicillin online

  16. Pingback: pic5678

  17. Pingback: 南越谷 クライミング

  18. Pingback: Ventilatie

  19. Pingback: English Bulldogs for sale near me

  20. Pingback: glo cartridges

  21. Pingback: sbo

  22. Pingback: meal plan 1200 calories low carb

  23. Pingback: The Fortune Games® App

  24. Pingback: marlin model 336

  25. Pingback: The guilty secrets keeping Britons awake at night: One in 20 people say they have a secret family while others hide food around their home from their partners

  26. Pingback: kardinal stick

  27. Pingback: relx

  28. Pingback: Illuminati Germany

  29. Pingback: Our site

  30. Pingback: Buy Kimber Firearms Online

  31. Pingback: here

  32. Pingback: block screenshot

  33. Pingback: Pulse Power plans

  34. Pingback: Sig Sauer Guns For Sale

  35. Pingback: mushroom gummies canada

  36. Pingback: 1p lsd

  37. Pingback: สล็อต เครดิตฟรี 100 ไม่ต้องฝาก

  38. Pingback: Best place to buy psilocybe cubensis

  39. Pingback: Paket Honeymoon Bali

  40. Pingback: TKO Extracts is a recreational cannabis & Medical Marijuana Online Dispensary

  41. Pingback: psilocybin mushrooms

  42. Pingback: Peoria

  43. Pingback: Workers call in sick more than any other UK city

  44. Pingback: junk removal near me

  45. Pingback: 스포츠방송

  46. Pingback: https://claimbo.com/company/zen-dojo/

  47. Pingback: Thermoforming packaging machine

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

More in LGBT issues

Gay Travel Magazine

To Top
%%FOOTER%%